Olivia Rodrigo Surprises Fans With ‘Drop Dead’ Performance at NYC Open Mic

Olivia Rodrigo gave a small Brooklyn crowd a major surprise Sunday night (April 26), popping up unannounced at a New York City open mic to perform her new single “Drop Dead.”

The appearance took place at Pete’s Candy Store in Williamsburg, a low-key venue better known for showcasing emerging artists than hosting one of pop’s biggest stars. Rodrigo’s stripped-back performance quickly spread online, with attendees sharing clips and reactions after realizing who had just taken the stage.

The moment comes as Rodrigo builds momentum toward her third studio album, You Seem Pretty Sad For A Girl So In Love, due June 12 via Geffen. “Drop Dead” has already become a focal point of the rollout, following its live debut earlier this month during a surprise appearance at Addison Rae’s Coachella set.

At the Brooklyn open mic, the song took on a different shape. Without the scale of a festival stage, Rodrigo delivered a pared-down version that leaned into the track’s emotional core.

The surprise set is part of a wider run of smaller, under-the-radar performances tied to the album’s release. Just days earlier, Rodrigo played an invite-only show at Los Angeles venue The Echo, where she was joined by Weyes Blood and debuted additional new material.

“Drop Dead” also includes a lyrical nod to The Cure, referencing “Just Like Heaven.” The connection traces back to Rodrigo’s 2025 Glastonbury set, where she brought out Robert Smith for live performances of “Friday I’m in Love” and “Just Like Heaven.”

Rodrigo’s ability to command both massive festival stages and small rooms has been central to her rise. Her 2023 album GUTS debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200, while singles including “vampire” and “bad idea right?” reached the top 10 on the Billboard Hot 100.